On what terms could the war in Ukraine stop?

Power cuts person not sapped Ukraine’s volition to fight. But they are a reminder that, 8 months aft his unprovoked invasion, Mr Putin keeps looking for ways to rise the stakes. Some interest helium mightiness stroke up a dam connected the Dnieper river, arsenic Stalin did successful 1941, to dilatory his adversaries’ advance.

The ever-evolving Russian battle besides raises an awkward question: however agelong volition America and Europe support providing Ukraine with the billions of dollars’ worthy of subject and economical assistance it needs each period to fend Russia off? “For arsenic agelong arsenic it takes," accidental Western leaders. But galore of their citizens cull the thought of bankrolling an indefinite struggle with Russia. Tens of thousands of radical took to the streets of Rome connected November 5th, calling for an extremity to the fighting. “We don’t privation war. No weapons, nary sanctions. Where is diplomacy?" work 1 placard.

Wary Washington

In America, too, questions person been raised. Hard-left Democrats precocious issued a call, swiftly retracted, for negotiations. Gains by America-first Republicans successful the midterm elections connected November 8th, though smaller than expected, are a reminder that American authorities mightiness alteration dramatically aft the adjacent statesmanlike election, successful 2 years’ time, and with it argumentation connected Ukraine.

Jake Sullivan, Mr Biden’s national-security adviser, made an unannounced travel to Kyiv connected November 4th to committedness “unwavering" support. But helium besides urged Ukraine to deliberation astir aboriginal bid terms. It has since emerged that helium has been successful interaction with his Russian counterparts, to pass them not to usage atomic weapons. On November 9th Mr Biden said Russia and Ukraine would “lick their wounds" aft the conflict for Kherson, and mightiness past beryllium acceptable for compromise. He insisted helium would not archer Ukraine what to do.

In private, Western and Ukrainian officials are starting to ponder what a unchangeable result mightiness look like. Will Ukraine go a caller Finland, forced to cede onshore to its invaders and to stay neutral for decades? Or different West Germany, with its nationalist territory partitioned by warfare and its antiauthoritarian fractional absorbed into NATO? A much-discussed template is Israel, a state nether changeless menace that has been capable to support itself without ceremonial alliances but with extended subject assistance from America.

The precise presumption of immoderate negotiated colony beryllium connected what happens connected the battlefield. There is apt to beryllium a batch much warring earlier either broadside is acceptable to extremity the war. Russia and Ukraine person each lost, by 1 estimate, astir 100,000 soldiers, killed and wounded, but some inactive anticipation to manoeuvre to a much favourable position.

The retreat from Kherson is simply a humiliation for Mr Putin. But it volition springiness Russian forces a much easy defended enactment on the Dnieper river. Mr Putin shows nary motion of throwing successful the towel. He has mobilised hundreds of thousands much recruits. Some person been rushed into conflict with small grooming oregon instrumentality to clasp the line; the remainder whitethorn beryllium utilized for a renewed propulsion adjacent year.

Ukraine, for its part, hopes to support its momentum. Its service is getting reinforcements this winter, successful the signifier of thousands of recruits trained by Britain and different Western countries. Western arms proceed to arrive. On November 4th the Pentagon announced different arms package, worthy $400m, including 45 refurbished T-72B tanks and 1,100 drones. The archetypal caller NASAMS anti-aircraft batteries were deployed this week.

The West’s stocks of weapons are not unlimited. European armies person eaten heavy into theirs; adjacent mighty America worries astir eroding its ain quality to combat aboriginal wars. It is Russia, however, that seems to look the astir contiguous shortages. It has utilized up astir of its precision bombs and missiles, and is struggling to regenerate them due to the fact that of sanctions. It is obtaining caller weapons from the likes of Iran and possibly North Korea. (China has truthful acold heeded American warnings to enactment retired of the war.)

Cold calculation

Mr Putin is hoping his run to destruct Ukraine’s energy grid volition frost the state into submission, oregon astatine slightest crook it into a weak, failing state. But the grounds of past conflicts is that aerial bombing of civilians, successful the lack of an effectual crushed campaign, seldom secures victory. Nearly 90% of Ukrainians privation the state to support fighting.

In Russia, according to the Levada Centre, a pollster, lone 36% privation to property connected with the war, whereas 57% favour bid talks. At the aforesaid time, enactment for Mr Putin remains astatine 79%. Russians, it seems, would similar the warfare to extremity but, starved of impartial news, bash not blasted Mr Putin for it. Still, the much helium tries to dragoon them into fighting, the much helium risks losing fashionable support.

Ukraine’s much avid Western supporters deliberation that, with time, Ukraine volition go stronger, and Russia weaker. But Mr Putin is hoping that “General Winter" volition someway revive his fortunes, if not by weakening Ukraine’s volition to combat past by gnawing astatine the West’s readiness to enactment it, arsenic the heating bills balloon successful Europe.

Mr Putin claims that helium is acceptable to negociate (from the starting constituent that the West should recognise his theft of Ukrainian territory) but that Ukraine’s Western “masters" person prevented it from talking. The 2 sides held lengthy talks aft Russia seized the Crimean peninsula and portion of Donbas successful 2014. They talked again successful the spring, arsenic Russia besieged Kyiv. But Ukraine acceptable its look against further negotiations aft Russia’s retreat from Kyiv successful April revealed wide atrocities against civilians. Volodymyr Zelensky, Ukraine’s president, suggested this week that talks could beryllium revived, but lone if Russia was consenting to springiness backmost Ukrainian land, wage compensation and judge work for warfare crimes.

The West is vague astir its ain aims. Mr Biden has astatine times mused astir wanting to spot Mr Putin ousted from power; astatine others helium has talked astir uncovering “off-ramps" for the Russian leader. He defined his goals astir intelligibly successful a impermanent nonfiction successful the New York Times successful May: “a democratic, independent, sovereign and prosperous Ukraine with the means to deter and support itself against further aggression". Notably, that near retired the question of Ukraine’s borders. Western leaders accidental this is for Ukraine to decide; their purpose is to fortify its negotiating hand.

More recently, though, Ukraine’s backers person sounded much specific. In a connection connected October 11th, leaders of the G7 radical of industrialised countries offered their “full enactment to Ukraine’s independence, territorial integrity and sovereignty successful its internationally recognised borders". They demanded that Russia “completely and unconditionally withdraw" from each seized lands. Among different things, they pledged to find ways of utilizing seized Russian assets to assistance money Ukraine’s reconstruction.

“The G7 connection is fundamentally a request for full Russian surrender, which is not a plausible diplomatic outcome. Diplomacy by explanation involves springiness and take. The anticipation should not beryllium different Treaty of Versailles," says Samuel Charap of the RAND Corporation, an American think-tank, referring to the punitive presumption imposed connected Germany astatine the extremity of the archetypal satellite war. The West, Ukraine and Russia, helium argues, should commencement talking, if lone to acceptable the groundwork for much substantive negotiations successful future: “Fighting and talking astatine the aforesaid clip should beryllium the norm."

Many disagree. “Keep up the pressure. Don’t beryllium successful a hurry to gully lines connected a map. It would beryllium bureaucratic suicide. Somebody volition enactment it up connected Twitter alongside the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact," retorts Dan Fried of the Atlantic Council, different American think-tank, alluding to Nazi Germany’s and the Soviet Union’s carve-up of Poland successful 1939.

Few Western leaders question Ukraine’s ambition to recapture the territory mislaid since Russia invaded successful February. Many would enactment efforts to reclaim the parts of Donbas seized successful 2014. But sentiment is much divided erstwhile it comes to reconquering Crimea. Many interest that the imaginable of losing the peninsula mightiness punctual a unsafe escalation from Mr Putin.

To immoderate successful the Biden administration, the warfare is simply a substance of principle: territory should ne'er beryllium seized by force, truthful each Russian gains indispensable beryllium reversed. Others, doubting Ukraine’s quality to reconquer overmuch more, deliberation the clip for diplomacy is soon. Either way, America is successful nary unreserved to spell retired diplomatic positions that mightiness origin rifts successful the pro-Ukraine camp.

Another pressing interest is the quality of aboriginal Western information guarantees for Ukraine. They volition request to beryllium robust fixed that Russia volition astir apt stay a menace to Ukraine for arsenic agelong arsenic Mr Putin is successful power, if not longer. Several cardinal and eastbound European countries favour Ukraine’s accelerated admittance to NATO, connected the grounds that the alliance’s committedness to communal defence would firmly deter Russia. For each its atomic menaces, it has truthful acold refrained from overtly striking NATO territory.

The Biden administration, though, is wary of having to widen its atomic umbrella to a state successful a authorities of latent oregon existent struggle with Russia. Throughout, Mr Biden has been cautious to minimise the hazard of a nonstop NATO-Russia struggle for fearfulness that it would pb to “World War III". Several NATO members successful occidental Europe are likewise sceptical.

So attraction has turned to interim, oregon alternative, arrangements. In September Anders Fogh Rasmussen, a erstwhile secretary-general of NATO, and Andriy Yermak, Mr Zelensky’s main of staff, projected a “Kyiv Security Compact" which would connection information assistance abbreviated of a mutual-defence pact. Some successful Ukraine considered it a betrayal. Modelled connected Western enactment for Israel, astir which Mr Zelensky has spoken, the compact would fortify Ukraine’s equipped forces—in effect turning the existent advertisement hoc enactment into a systematic, semipermanent commitment.

Ukraine’s partners would committedness “multi-decade" investments successful the country’s defence industry, monolithic weapons transfers, training, associated exercises and quality support. The compact would necessitate neither Russia’s assent nor Ukraine’s neutrality. It would not preclude NATO membership. In immoderate circumstances, determination could beryllium subject involution to assistance Ukraine. If it were attacked, the signatories would “use each elements of their nationalist and corporate powerfulness and instrumentality due measures—which whitethorn see diplomatic, economical and subject means." A wider radical of countries, including Asian allies, would reenforce specified subject assistance with sanctions connected Russia, including provisions to “snap back" immoderate of the existent penalties that whitethorn beryllium lifted arsenic portion of a deal.

Even this whitethorn beryllium excessively ambitious for Team Biden. Some ask, for instance, what commitments Ukraine would instrumentality on, by mode of reforms to fortify democracy, say, oregon to combat corruption. The parallel with Israel is imperfect. Among different things, Israel is simply a atomic powerfulness and occupies Arab land. For Mykola Bielieskov of the National Institute for Strategic Studies, a think-tank successful Kyiv, the Israeli exemplary “is not lone astir mobilising our partners externally; it’s besides astir explaining to radical what it means to unrecorded adjacent doorway to a brainsick neighbour, to existential threats."

The entity indispensable beryllium the limit

Whatever the diplomatic template, Russia’s blitz has proved that the West volition request to assistance Ukraine make a decently integrated and layered air-defence system, mixing combatant aircraft, surface-to-air batteries and shoulder-launched weapons. At the infinitesimal weapons are arriving piecemeal and often cannot speech data. There are besides worries astir Ukraine moving retired of definite types of air-defence munitions. If that were to hap Russia could past deploy overmuch much aerial powerfulness successful enactment of crushed troops.

Ukraine’s mix-and-match weapons—a “Mr Potato Head" arsenal, arsenic immoderate telephone it—cause problems elsewhere. For instance, it has nary less than 14 antithetic types of artillery pieces, with an mean brigade operating 4 antithetic sorts. “This is simply a logistical nightmare for them, particularly erstwhile we speech astir ammunition," says Nick Reynolds of RUSI, a British think-tank. Some of the weapons are wearing retired badly, and Europe’s defence industry, sapped by decades of debased spending, is poorly placed to nutrient spare parts. “Red lights are flashing successful presumption of that enactment being available," adds Mr Reynolds.

How agelong the warfare goes connected depends chiefly connected Mr Putin. He is successful a bind, some successful Ukraine and astatine home. Moderate technocrats are disquieted astir the strains connected the economy; “national patriots" specified arsenic Yevgeny Prigozhin, who commands the Wagner mercenary group, person called for purges of supposedly treacherous generals.

A intermission to play astatine diplomacy whitethorn suit Mr Putin for a time—particularly if it allows him to consolidate immoderate territorial gains. That whitethorn explicate his caller toning down of atomic rhetoric and his abrupt casting of Ukrainians arsenic victims of Western aggression. “The West is throwing Ukrainians into a furnace"; Russia, successful contrast, “has ever treated Ukrainian radical with respect," Mr Putin declared connected November 4th. (His propagandists and officials, though, inactive speech of “de-Satanising" Ukraine.) The displacement fits different of Mr Putin’s guises, arsenic the champion of a planetary question to formed disconnected Western dominance.

In each this Mr Putin is seeking to woo waverers, particularly successful the planetary South. He besides wants to reassure friends specified arsenic China and India, which person made plain their disapproval of his atomic recklessness. Above each Mr Putin is funny successful reaching 1 rich-world listener: Donald Trump, whose allies successful Congress question American assistance to Ukraine and who whitethorn soon denote different tally for president.

For each his setbacks, Mr Putin is not yet retired of options to persecute Ukraine and effort to disagreement the West. Militarily, helium could perpetrate much of his aerial unit and mobilise much troops. In the covert “grey zone" helium could sabotage undersea state pipelines and net connections to the West, behaviour bigger cyber-attacks, interfere with communications satellites and measurement up disinformation campaigns. He could besides descend ships carrying atom from Ukraine. Ultimately, helium could usage tactical atomic weapons. All this, though, would travel astatine dense cost: it would marque Russia adjacent much of a pariah, weaken him astatine location and mightiness provoke harsh retaliation.

The stakes are higher for Mr Putin than for the West. But they are highest for Ukrainians, galore of whom mistrust the precise thought of talks with Russia and spot subject triumph arsenic their lone option—even if it takes years to achieve. The much onshore it tin regain, Ukraine reckons, the greater the accidental of getting escaped of Mr Putin. Yet that aforesaid imaginable alarms galore successful the West: a rout of the Russian service mightiness beryllium what pushes Mr Putin to spell nuclear. That is 1 crushed wherefore Team Biden agelong agone stopped talking astir helping Ukraine “win".

As it has often done with Israel, America whitethorn astatine immoderate constituent effort to bounds Ukraine’s ambitions. It request not bash truthful overtly; it tin simply withhold the arms Ukraine needs, arsenic it already does to an extent. It declines to supply Western aircraft, Patriot air-defence missiles and longer-range ATACMS onslaught missiles for fearfulness that they mightiness goad Russia to usage atomic weapons.

All this explains wherefore immoderate Ukrainians person been circulating a bittersweet connection issued to Finnish troops successful 1940 astatine the extremity of the “Winter War" with the Soviet Union by their commander, Carl Gustaf Mannerheim. The vastly outnumbered Finns had inflicted dense losses connected Soviet forces but nevertheless had to cede territory due to the fact that assistance from their friends had dried up, Mannerheim wrote, signing disconnected with the words, “We are proudly conscious of the historical work which we shall proceed to fulfil; the defence of that Western civilisation which has been our practice for centuries, but we cognize besides that we person paid to the precise past penny immoderate indebtedness we whitethorn person owed the West."

Ukraine’s destiny depends not conscionable connected the valour of its soldiers oregon resilience of its people, but besides connected outer factors it cannot control: the inscrutable calculations of Russia’s despotic ruler and the fortitude of its friends. The benefits to the West of the warfare are already clear. Russia has been enormously weakened, making Europe’s flank overmuch easier to defend. For Ukraine, which has suffered horrific losses, the result looks overmuch little certain.

Visit our revised Ukraine hub to work the champion of our sum of the war

© 2023, The Economist Newspaper Limited. All rights reserved. From The Economist, published nether licence. The archetypal contented tin beryllium recovered connected www.economist.com